PHR Student Program Mid-Atlantic Regional Hub

PHR members are invited to attend the Boston Initiative to Advance Human Rights’ sex trafficking film forum event at the Brattle Theater in Cambridge, MA, from December 2 through December 5. The festival, which is the first of its kind, will screen 12 films, which will be followed by panel discussions with filmmakers, academics, and activists.

The film forum will explore the power of film in bringing about a movement to combat commercial sexual exploitation and modern-day slavery. PHR recently blogged about this issue.

Additional events include an opening night live performance by Tony award-winning actress and humanitarian Sarah Jones, followed by a cocktail hour with hors d’oeuvres by legendary chef Lydia Shire of Scampo, music performance, and a silent auction. On Saturday there will be a book signing with Siddharth Kara, author of Sex Trafficking: Inside the Business of Modern Slavery.

Tickets are available for purchase now. Discounted tickets are available for students, seniors, and non-profits.

Learn more, including film titles and times, at BITAHR’s the official website, and at their Facebook page.
.

Only 37% of Ugandan physicians are satisfied with their jobs and nearly half are at risk of either exiting the health sector or leaving Uganda entirely, according to a study published this year by the International Journal of Health Planning and Management. The study, “Satisfaction, Motivation, and Intent to Stay Among Ugandan Physicians,” is co-authored by Emily Bancroft, a former Leland Fellow with PHR in the US and AGHA in Uganda. Dovetailing with PHR’s previous works on health worker shortages in Africa, the study’s results come from a sample group of physicians working in 18 public and private health facilities in Uganda representing approximately 3% of Ugandan physicians. This study came about at the behest of Uganda’s Ministry of Health, which hopes to analyze how to implement effective policy reforms to strengthen and expand their health workforce. Bancroft’s team, headed by long time PHR advisor Professor Amy Hagopian of the University of Washington, urges Ugandan policy-makers to intervene to stem the “brain drain” that is heightened by factors such as low wages, poor infrastructure and materials, few opportunities to progress within the medical field, and regional isolation for doctors outside large cities.

14% of Ugandan physicians emigrate abroad, largely to four English-speaking countries—the US, Canada, the UK, and Australia. This number is significantly lower than that of some other countries in peril. For example, it is frequently said that more Malawian doctors practice in Manchester, England, than in the entire country of Malawi. Although Uganda’s health workforce shortage seems less drastic than Malawi’s, the crisis is no less dire: in 2008, the study’s authors estimated that there are only 2,500 physicians for Uganda’s 31 million inhabitants. Physicians, far more so than other Ugandan health professionals, were seen by Bancroft and colleagues as dissatisfied with their work and both ready and capable of vacating their posts if the opportunity should arise. Along with nurses, physicians are the group most heavily courted by international recruiters, which means many of the physicians Bancroft spoke with may already have found an opportunity to leave Uganda.

The World Bank and International Monetary Fund have exacerbated the “brain drain” seen in Uganda and throughout Africa with “structural adjustment” policies that cap domestic health expenditures. Wealthy countries can offer doctors higher salaries, greater career advancement opportunities, and, in many cases, a more stable political environment in which to work.

The Global HEALTH Act, introduced by Rep. Barbara Lee in March 2010, would assist Uganda’s efforts and help curtail health workforce shortages in countries facing similar crises by providing $2 billion over five years to increase the number of physicians, nurses, and other health workers in developing countries—and to help retain those health workers already there. The bill not only authorizes new resources, it also calls for the creation of a US Global Health Strategy to complement the goals of countries like Uganda and ensure US aid money goes where it can make a difference. This study will help foreign aid innovations like the Global HEALTH Act to better tackle complex problems like brain drain and to work with communities to solve these challenges—something PHR is dedicated to helping support.

Two years ago, Kamiar Alaei, MD, and Arash Alaei, MD, were arrested in Iran, just as they were preparing to leave for Mexico to present on their innovative harm reduction work at the XVII International AIDS Conference.

On July 18, the world convenes again for the XVIII International AIDS Conference in Vienna, Austria — but will be short two shining stars. Arash and Kamiar remain in jail today. The Iranian government accused the brothers of using trips to AIDS and public health conferences around the world to “foment a velvet revolution” and sentenced them to years in prison. We say treating AIDS is not a crime.

Friends and colleagues of the Alaeis will be in Vienna spreading the word about their case and advocating for their release, and PHR will be supporting them all the way.

Will you be in Vienna at the AIDS conference? To volunteer with these efforts, email Clint Trout at clintworldwide [at] yahoo [dot] com.

Want to take action to support the Alaeis? Sign our new petition, calling on the government of Iran to free the Alaeis.

Throughout their careers, the Alaeis have promoted public health diplomacy and supported the quest for shared solutions to the world’s shared disease burden. It is an outrage to call this treason. Medical professionals should not be put in prison for doing their jobs. Take action today and stand in solidarity with the Alaeis.

See the Background page at IranFreeTheDocs.org for more information on their case.

Physicians for Human Rights joins numerous international NGOs, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Reporters Without Borders, in supporting United4Iran’s Global Day of Action on June 12, 2010. June 12 events will be occurring in over 70 cities around the world. Go to 12June.org for more information.

June 12 marks the one year anniversary of Iran’s disputed election, which was followed by a government crackdown that saw an increase in arbitrary arrests, torture, and politically motivated use of the death penalty. The Global Day of Action calls attention to Prisoners of Conscience in Iran, and demands their unconditional release.

Since last year’s elections, the human rights situation in Iran has only grown worse. PHR continues to highlight the case of Drs. Kamiar and Arash Alaei, Iranian doctors who have been held by Iranian authorities since June 2008. After being imprisoned without charge for six months, the Doctors Alaei were convicted and sentenced for the charges of being in “communications with an enemy government” and “seeking to overthrow the Iranian government.” Kamiar was given a three year prison sentence, while Arash was sentenced to six years.

The Iranian government used the doctors’ travel to international AIDS conferences as a basis for the charge. Iran cannot continue to imprison medical professions for doing their job. By equating public health diplomacy with treason, the Iranian government poses a threat to all Iranians working for scientific knowledge.

Stand with PHR and the international community to tell the world that “Treating AIDS is not a crime.” Visit iranfreethedocs.org for more information on the Alaeis. And on June 12, please help us remember and defend those in Iran jailed for their humanitarian work.

On May 10th, The New York Times published a heartrending story on the faltering fight against AIDS in Uganda — a story that has sparked a firestorm of controversy and criticism of the Obama Administration’s global AIDS strategy.

The Times identified a deep funding gap for combating AIDS in Uganda, including a freeze on new funds from the United States and a lack of commitment to AIDS spending by the Ugandan government (which evidently has no problem finding $300 million to spend on Russian fighter jets). The Times also outlined the devastating human toll this funding gap is taking on people living with — and dying of — AIDS.

Sadly, this news is not new. In March 2009, PHR invited Dr. Peter Myugenyi, Founder and Director of the PEPFAR-supported Joint Clinical Research Centre in Uganda, to Washington, DC to talk about the emerging funding gap for AIDS in Uganda. Said Dr. Mugyenyi:

After urging people to get tested and enter care, we now have to tell them there is no treatment available when they need it. We created hope and now we are returning to the days when one member of a family can get treatment and the others cannot.

It is a recipe for chaos as patients start to share doses or skip treatment altogether. I fear that we will soon start to see more drug-resistant strains of HIV and rising death rates.

As The Times notes, one year later, Dr. Myugenyi remains fearful:

Dr. Peter Mugyenyi, the hospital’s founder, helped the Bush administration form its AIDS plan and sat beside Laura Bush during the State of the Union address as it was announced.

The loss of donor interest “makes me frantic with worry,” Dr. Mugyenyi said.

He offers copies of e-mail messages he exchanged with American aid officials. One reminds him that he has been instructed to stop enrolling new patients and asks for an explanation of reports that he is treating 37,000 when only 32,000 are authorized. Another asks him not to announce publicly that his funds have been frozen.

He admits slipping pregnant women and young mothers like Ms. Kamukama into treatment slots “contrary to instructions.”

“Morally, I can’t turn them away,” he said.

This story gained traction worldwide, and was followed by a New York Times editorial, The Wavering War on AIDS, which outlined a $13 billion deficit in AIDS spending, and a series of letters to the editor, including one by PHR Global Health Action Campaign advisor Pat Daoust.

Dr. Mugyenyi won’t turn away patients. And we won’t turn away from this issue.

PHR, in conjuction with other global health groups, sent a letter to Secretary of State Clinton last week, urging her to end the AIDS funding freeze and ensure Ugandans have access to life-saving AIDS treatment.

PHR members have spent years advocating for more global AIDS funding and health programming based on science and human rights. We will continue to fight for greater global health funding, a strong US global health strategy, and to ensure people living with AIDS worldwide have access to drugs and quality care.

Want to help? Encourage your Representative to co-sponsor the Global HEALTH Act, which will provide $2 billion for health system strengthening and support a comprehensive US global health strategy, both of which will help in the fight against AIDS.

The health workforce crisis in Uganda is immense. Uganda is reportedly losing at least 1,400 skilled professionals each year, and there are only 29,000 medical personnel in a country of 31 million people. Consequently, the health system is suffering, and most often the blame falls on health workers, as they are on the frontline and seemingly represent the health sector. In the past eight months, since I’ve been in Uganda, media coverage of the health system has almost always focused on the negative aspects of health workers, further demonizing a field that is made up largely of hard working people.

Recent Ugandan headlines include:

Rioters attack Mityana hospital” (New Vision, Aug 21, 2009)

12 Health workers held over drug theft” (New Vision, Jan 11, 2010)

Health officials remanded over theft of government drugs” (Daily Monitor, Mar 11, 2010)

These news stories reflect the public’s negative perception of health workers, who are almost always associated with being unqualified, incompetent, rude, corrupt, and thieves. Furthermore, personal stories shared with me about using the health system are most often about being ignored and mistreated — not about receiving good care by caring health workers.

For those of us advocating for health workforce development, the negative image of health workers makes it more difficult to garner support and foster dialogue. We should honor the truth of people’s experiences with health workers and the health system, but the problem is complex and there are many underlying factors that need to be addressed. Health workers are overworked, underpaid, and lack proper resources and equipment. Yet the majority of health workers still show up to work and perform their duties. If they didn’t, the health system would completely collapse. At the same time, we should expect and demand a standard of care from our health workers.

Ugandan nurse Mitterand Kiirya (Physicians for Human Rights)

Given the complexity of the issue and the lack of easy answers, I wanted to highlight one health worker who I feel exemplifies the notion of a dedicated and ethical health worker. Mitterand Kiirya is a research nurse for the Antiretrovirals for Kaposi’s Sarcoma (ARKS) study at the Infectious Disease Institute (IDI) at Mulago Hospital, the largest national referral hospital in Kampala, Uganda. For the past 2½ years, he has been working with HIV-positive patients who have Kaposi’s Sarcoma. Previously, Mitterand worked at Uganda Cares, an antiretroviral access initiative in Masaka.

I first heard about Mitterand through my roommate, a U.S. medical student working with him at IDI. She would often talk about his dedication, and how he would invite her to join him on visits to the countryside 6–7 hours away from Kampala to check in on his patients in their homes. This was not part of his duties, but something he did on his own time. But most of all, she would always talk about how he inspired her to be a good doctor, because he always put the patient first. And, despite all the challenges he faced, he always remained positive and managed to smile and make people laugh everyday.

Here are some highlights from a recent conversation I had with Mitterand:

Why did you want to become a nurse?

It was from watching my mother. She is a mid-wife in my village, Namugong, Kaliro [in the Eastern part of Uganda]. I watched her passion for her patients. How she cared for them, wanting to alleviate their pain. What I saw was that she tried to understand the patient, and I wanted to do the same thing.

What does it mean to understand your patient?

Well…before seeing the doctor, the patient has a lot of anxiety, especially when they are referred from place to place. So I try to sit and talk to them before they see the doctor, prepare them to receive what the doctor will tell them.

What do you see as the role of the nurse?

As a nurse, I try to reverse what was impossible, and make it possible. I try to bring a message of hope and new life, especially with my patients who are HIV-positive. If you haven’t even given the message of assurance, then it’s the equivalent of not having come to work that day.

People have encouraged me to further my studies, and become a doctor. I have thought about it a lot, but I don’t want to lose the contact with my patients, which I think happens sometimes with doctors. So, right now, I’m staying a nurse, staying with my patients.

You often see that nurses, or health workers in general, get discouraged by their work environment. What do you think about this?

Yes, I do see some of my colleagues who are not working. But what I try to do is motivate them. Remind them about the ethical requirements of our profession, but also try to serve as an example for them too. But, I tell them that “ we are here to serve our profession, give the service and think about the quality of your services, the quality of your service should determine your cost”. But you must work hard.

I know the system is broken. Infrastructure is inadequate, and the environment is making it difficult. We are losing the confidentiality of the patient, because we are sharing spaces with only curtains to divide, and sometimes not even that. I am always trying to improvise to keep the patients alive.

How do you stay motivated?

I have love for the patients. That is what motivates me. Be their friend, we need to be there first for the patients.

Tell me about the award you received from Alicia Keys.

When I was working at Uganda Cares in Masaka, she contributed ARVs and general support for HIV-positive children. She found me at Masaka, working as a nurse, she was told through my director, my medical director, Dr. Bernard Okongo. He introduced me as a hardworking nurse, who was dedicated with total love for his profession. I received an award and took a picture with her. It was a big ceremony held in Masaka.

I felt very…actually felt humbled really, for the public to appreciate my contribution and my profession, I felt humbled. I felt so humbled. In this country, what de-motivates people, you can serve, but failure to appreciate your service is another big issue. If the services we are offering are appreciated, the level of our service would be so high.

Thanks Mitterand for speaking with me.

No, I say ‘thank you’ to you, because you are listening to me. Everyday, I am here for others, listening to them, and having to hold back my pain. But it’s nice that I can talk and you listen to me.

Speaking with Mitterand is always inspiring, and I know he is not the exception. From my experience in Uganda, I have witnessed the dedication of health workers throughout the country, ranging from district health officials to field doctors and nurses and community health workers. Further, I have seen administrators, Ministry of Health officials and policymakers who are also working tirelessly to improve the health of the population. I think it’s important for us in advocacy to re-frame the issue of health workers, by highlighting the positive aspects of their work and recognizing them for it, so that the media and general public can better understand them and the complexities of the Human Resources for Health issue. And we need health workers to also speak out and show their commitment and concern for the health of the population, because in the end, we are all working towards a collective goal to ensure the right to health for all.

We’re just a month away from World Health Day (April 7th) and the official launch of advocacy for the Global HEALTH Act of 2010. So far this month, through this blog you’ve learned about the Global HEALTH Act and gotten some great facts about the health workforce crisis (and how many people are waiting in line for an I-Pad — impressive!). Today’s post includes a few more resources that highlight the impact of Africa’s health workforce shortage. Check them out and share with colleagues.

PHR made the following video in collaboration with our Kenyan partner group, the Health Rights Advocacy Forum. In this 6-minute video, four health workers at Mbagathi Hospital talk about  the challenges they face every day — and why they stay and practice medicine in their home country. This moving video can be shown on campus or at your workplace to stimulate discussion and urge people to take action.

For more personal stories, check out Africa’s Health Care Worker Crisis: Views from the Ground, a PowerPoint presentation that outlines six main drivers of the health workforce crisis in Africa and explores these challenges through the eyes of four Ugandan medical student leaders. Feel free to use this to make a presentation on campus or in your community, or use facts from it to drive home the need for action.

And watch our slideshows of Dr. Fred Katumba and Clinical Officer Jane Byarugaba following them through a typical day as they provide health care to the rural poor in Southwestern Uganda. Dr. Katumba’s work has propelled Lyantonde District to #2 out of more than 90 districts in terms of health outcomes — a phenomenal accomplishment and testament to Dr. Katumba, his staff, and the millions of hard-working health professionals who help communities realize the right to health every day.